How can a day celebrating women be a bad thing?
It is a bad thing in many, many ways: first, what in particular are we celebrating about women? That they’re women? Hoo, women exist. Great prizes for good little girls for existing.
Yes, I know what gets accreted to it: women who fought for equality. women who still fight for equality in dangerous places (like say Afghanistan), women who’ve invented things, women who’ve done special things.
And that’s fine and dandy, but WHY are we celebrating IN PARTICULAR women who did these things? It is impossible to avoid the feeling that it’s not normal for women to do these things, and that’s why they need to be PARTICULARLY celebrated for having them.
I mean, I want to make clear that I do admire people who do admirable things. I just find the implication that doing admirable things while female is not that unusual; that we are not, in fact, impaired children who need to be given special prizes for existing. Why else would you celebrate WOMEN who do special things more than anyone else who does special things, unless it is because women are naturally inferior and can’t do special things.
So eventually I boiled over, and posted this on the book of faces:
“Women’s Day” is how you know we’re speshull. Or at least that society at large considers us short bus speshull. Treating any group of people as though they need special recognition is like saying “Well done! We didn’t expect you lot to do anything. We’re so proud of you.”
I’m human and I partake of human achievement. What actually is between the legs of the people being celebrated couldn’t matter less to me. Or what they like to do with said equipment.
Unless we’re celebrating sex gods or goddesses, this is just nonsense and giving the impression some animals are more equal than others.
I’m celebrating by hoisting both middle fingers aloft. Lookit my matched set!
I confess I didn’t follow all the answers, partly because I’m trying to finish a book, but two of the answers I got were sadly illustrative.
One was the inevitable man asking me if I’d give the finger to all the women who fought for equality and bringing up the inevitable example of the young woman in Afghanistan who got shot for fighting for female education, and saying that “She should just have told those women they were whiners and should shut up.”
Need I say that admire everyone who fought for equality under the law, and still fights. And need I also say that International Women’s Day does nothing to advance that fight? Thinking that declaring an International Women’s Day will make the barbarians of Isis realize that women should have equal rights is typical of the Disney generation, who thinks everything bad is just a big misunderstanding and can be resolved with a song and dance or a big demonstration of some sort, with painless virtue signaling from “enlightened” people.
And yet, the lowest US infantryman sent to Afghanistan did more to advance the cause of freedom and human dignity, and, yes, female equality before the law than all of the “International Women’s Day”s of the world.